Sir Leszek calls for renewed understanding between science advisers and government
3 November 2009
Sir Leszek Borysiewicz, chief executive of the Medical Research Council expressed regret yesterday over the situation which has arisen since the recent dismissal of the chief drugs adviser to the Government, Professor David Nutt. He urged that steps must be taken to rebuild the relationship between scientists and the Government.
In response to Professor Nutt’s dismissal, Sir Leszek highlighted the need for scientists and policy-makers to work together effectively:
“The MRC wholeheartedly defends academic freedom and the need for scientists to present findings based on sound research. It is crucial that UK policy is based on evidence and that scientists are able to offer unfettered advice without the fear of reprisal. This principle should be the backbone of scientific engagement with government.”
Sir Leszek commented that the recent debate had left many scientists feeling anxious about what their position would be when giving scientific advice and were in need of reassurance that they would be listened to and that their findings would be accurately reported.
“It’s widely accepted that scientific evidence should shape rather than dictate government policy. It’s important that scientists who serve on government committees recognise that. Expert advisers must understand that ministers may sometimes reject their recommendations. However scientists must be allowed to speak freely and to offer that advice in an entirely unfettered way, otherwise that advice is actually counterproductive to government. I do feel it’s a matter of some urgency that the position is clarified so that we don't lose the confidence and expertise of other advisers.”
Sir Leszek outlined his position in a recent interview with The Times. The full article can be viewed here
Further information on the Medical Research Council’s aims for scientific policy engagement can be found as part of our Strategic Plan 2009 – 2014, Research changes lives
